Musavi and Karrubi: Iran’s Ailing Opposition Leaders

By Golnaz Esfandiari.Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty.Nov 21 2012,

Two of the country’s leading dissenters are in ill health.

Mousavi banner.jpg

Women walk past a picture of presidential candidate Mir Hossein Mousavi (R) and former President Mohammad Khatami (L) in Tehran on May 29, 2012. (Raheb Homavandi/Reuters)


Concern is growing over the health of Iranian opposition leaders Mir  Hossein Musavi and Mehdi Karrubi after opposition sources reported that  both men were hospitalized for several hours and underwent medical tests on November 19. Musavi; his wife, university professor and women’s rights activist Zahra Rahnavard; and Karrubi were put under house arrest in February 2010  after their call for a demonstration in support of the Arab Spring  uprisings brought a significant number of opposition members into the  streets.

Musavi has reportedly been suffering in recent weeks from chest pains  and extreme fluctuation of his blood pressure. In August, he  underwent an angiography for a heart condition that he is said to have  developed in detention.
Sahamnews, the website of fellow opposition cleric Mehdi Karrubi,  reports that Karrubi has recently lost a substantial amount of weight  and suffers from loss of appetite, nausea, and dizziness. Last year, he  allegedly suffered from respiratory complications. Family members and aides believe that the health of the men has deteriorated as the result of their detention.
Needs Constant Care
Musavi’s aide, Amir Arjomand, said that because of his condition, the 70-year-old former prime minister must be under constant medical  supervision. Yet he claimed that authorities at times have prevented  Musavi from receiving treatment, leading to increased worries over his  health.
Karrubi’s family has expressed concern over the health of the  75-year-old and issued a statement on November 20 calling on authorities to allow him to be treated by doctors they trust. “We expect his right to access independent treatment will be officially  recognized so that medical follow-up under the supervision of trusted  family doctors can take place in one of Tehran’s hospitals,” the  statement said.
Musavi and Rahnavard are being held at their residence in Tehran.  Karrubi has been confined to a house in the capital controlled by  security forces. According to his son, Taghi, his family is contributing to the rent.Both opposition figures are banned from contact with the outside world, except for occasional meetings with their children. Arjomand, Musavi’s aide, said Musavi’s family has been threatened by the authorities and warned not to inform the public about the conditions of their parents.
Standing Firm
Karrubi’s family has also been under pressure. One of the cleric’s sons  was recently banned from meeting his father, apparently after informing  him about political developments. Taghi Karrubi told RFE/RL that despite the difficult conditions he  faces, his father remains in good spirits and stands firm on his  positions. “[Karrubi] entered on this path well aware of the difficulties and he has remained steadfast on this difficult path,” he says. Relatives of Musavi say his stances also remain unchanged.
The clerics’ unwillingness to abandon their reformist platforms — and  their continued popularity — appear to be the reasons why authorities  have kept them under house arrest. Arjomand said the authorities should either put Musavi, Rahnavard, and Karrubi on trial or free them. “Four years have passed since the 2009 election,” he says, “and we’re  nearing another presidential vote. [The authorities] have put three  people under arrest for three years for no reason.

If they have any  reason or proof [of their crimes], they should put them on trial. If  [the opposition figures] have lied, stolen, or committed treachery, [the authorities] have had four years to gather evidence. If there is no  evidence, they should release them.”
Both Musavi and Karrubi stood as presidential candidates in the disputed 2009 vote, which resulted in the reelection of Mahmud Ahmadinejad. They challenged the election results and accused the authorities of massive  fraud.

The clerics also criticized serious human rights abuses that took place during the state crackdown that followed the election. Hard-liners have previously called for the executions of Musavi and  Karrubi, whom they accuse of attempting to topple the Islamic  establishment. Some judiciary officials said following the election that the men would  be put on trial. Instead, authorities have chosen isolation.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s